Return to the main index

                        BLUE BOOK/PROJECT GRUDGE 

                    -=As always, by Bill Cooper=-

A series of PROJECT GRUDGE/BLUE BOOK reports have been released over the 
years in connection with the USAF's investigation into UFO's which was 
supposedly terminated with the release of the Condon report in the late 
1960's.  Reports one to twelve of GRUDGE/BLUE BOOK were generally 
innocuous and contained no classified or truly sensitive material.  
There was a final report, #14 which was widely circulated and about 
which an entire book was written: FLYING SAUCERS: An analysis of the air
force PROJECT BLUE BOOK special report NO. 14 by Leon Davidson: The 
fifth edition was published in 1976 by Blue-Book Publishers; 64 Prospect 
St., White Plains, New York 10606. 

Missing from public view, however, was report #13. 

Several years ago, Bill English, son of an Arizona state legislator and 
former captain in the Green Berets had been asigned to an RAF 'listening
post' north of London as an information analyst.  English was, in the 
course of his duties, asked to prepare an analysis of the elusive GRUDGE 
13 report.  On his discharge from his work at the 'listening post' he 
returned to the United States and began to do a little UFO research on 
his own.  English had been no stranger to the UFO phenomenon.  In 
Vietnam he was a member of a Special Forces investigative team that went 
in to retrieve a B-52 that was forced down by a UFO and all the 
occupants killed. Communications had been received from the B-52 before 
it went down to the effect that it was "...under attack by a UFO..", a 
"...large light...".  The plane was found intact, sitting in the jungle.  
There was no swath indicative of a crash landing.  Only the bottom of 
the fuselage showed any damage, there was no damage to the underside of 
the engine pods.  Although the plane was completely intact the entire 
crew had been mutilated. 

English, through contacts he still maintains has determined that the US 
Government 'most definitely' supports a 'project dealing specifically 
with UFO's and captured aliens'.  According to what he has learned, the 
US government captured a trio of aliens, and that as of mid 1981, one of 
the beings was still alive in captivity. English also claims that "at 
one point in the early 1950's until the mid 1960's the Air Force 
maintained relocation and debriefing colonies for people who had 
experienced close encounters of the 3rd and 4th kind. They were isolated 
for all intents and purposes for the rest of their lives. He doubts that 
these colonies are still in existence. 

English dictated 2 audio casettes outlining what he remembered from the 
Grudge 13 report.  These audio cassettes were transcribed into hand 
written notes by another person.  The information contained therein 
indicated what had been suspected all along: that the US government was 
involved in the greatest deception in the history of mankind and that 
not only did flying saucers exist but that the government had several in 
secret storage and had captured at least 3 live aliens. 

The following is a summary of what Bill English remembers from what he 
read during that day in June, 1977 of PROJECT GRUDGE/BLUE BOOK REPORT NO 

In Box, diplomatic pouch under lock and key system.  Lock had been 
opened, pouch was easily accessed.  Standard diplomatic couriers pouch 
marked American Embassy Couriers, contained pouch serial number JL327 
Delta (JL327D?).  Inside a publication with red tape which indicated 
code red security precautions and an Air Force disposition form.  
Disposition form was standard white page copy, title was 'Analysis 
Report'.  Further down was "Analyse enclosed report under code red 
measures. Give abstract breakdown and report on validity. Observe all 
code red measures. Analysis required immediately'. Underneath were a 
series of dashes then the letters NDF then another series of dashes.  
Below that, lower left hand corner were the initials WGB. 

Publication was withdrawn from pouch. It measured approximately 8" by 
11" with gray cover.  Heavily bound, paper back style similar to 
technical manuals.  Across the center front it read, "Grudge/Blue Book 
Report No. 13".  It was dated 1953-(1963).  In the lower right hand 
corner was AFSN 2246-3.  In upper left hand corner was the word 
'annotated'.  Across the front upper right hand corner to lower left 
hand corner was red tape indicating code red security measures. Across 
the front was stamped in red ink 'Top Secret Need To Know Only Crypto 
Clearance 14 Required' Inside front cover upper left hand corner were 
hand written notations in ink which were blacked out by black felt pen. 

Inside cover sheet was basically the same information as the cover.  
Second page was title page.  Next page after that was an appendix with 
numerous notations made in it.  Notations dealt with inserts of what 
appeared to be photos and additional notes.  At bottom of third page it 
read G/BV Page 1 of 624 pages.  Title page was subject letter.  Complete 
list of appendix not remembered.  Title.  Some notes on the practical 
applications of the Worst Nemo equations. 

Table of Contents, Part 1. "On the design of generators to accomplish 
strain free molecular translation". Part 2, "The generation of space 
time discontinuums, closed, open and folded".  Part 3, "On the 
generation of temporary pseudo acceleration locas".  Part 1, Chapter 1, 
"design criteria for a simple generator and control system referring to 
equation 17 appendix A".  Part 2 Chapter 1, "Continuation of Einsteins 
Theory of Relativity to final conclusion".  Part 3, Chapter 1, "Possible 
applications of Einsteinian theory of relativity at conclusion". Part 1, 
chapter 2, reports of UFO encounters, classification "Close Encounters 
of the 1st kind", subtitle sightings and witnesses.  Part 2, Chapter 2, 
"Close Encounters of the 2nd kind", subtitle UFO sightings witnessed 
within close proximity. Part 3, Chapter 2 "Close Encounters of the 3rd 
kind", subtitle UFO encounters and extraterrestrial life forms witnessed 
and personal encounters. Subtitle, "Colonies, relocation thereof".  Case 
histories.  Chapter 3 Part 1,titled "Military Encounters with UFO's". 
Part 2 Chapter 3, "Military Reports Concerning sightings on Radar and 
Electronic Surveillance of UFO's". Subsection 2, Analysis Report, J. 
Allen Hynek, LtCol. Friend. Appendix continued on for about 5 pages.  
Opening subject page consisted of a report of the findings as written by 
LtCol.  Friend and his analysis. 

Must stress at this point that the version seen was annotated.  There 
were inserts that were added to this copy after it had been initially 
printed.  Sections remembered very vividly are the photographs and the 
reports concerning captive sights of various UFO's to include Mexico, 
Sweden, United States and Canada. There were also what was then 
classified Close Encounters of the 3rd kind.  It was made very clear 
that these people whom it was determined had genuine CE 3's were move in 
the middle of the night by Air Force personnel and relocated to various 
sites in the midwest and northwest parts of the United kStates.  In many
cases these people experienced physical ailments from exposure to 
various types of radiation. 

One case especially noted and remembered very vividly was entitled 
'Darlington Farm Case' out of Ohio. Case apparently took place in 
October 1953.  Man, wife and 13 year old son were sitting down at dinner 
table.  As they sat there the lights in the farm house began to dim.  
Dogs and animals raised rucus on outside.  13 year old boy got up from 
dinner table to see what was going on.  Called his mother and father to 
come look at the funny lights in the sky.  Father and mother got up and 
as they got up the son went outside into the yard.  Father and mother 
went out onto the porch.  When they got out on the porch one of the dogs 
broke loose from leash beside house and came running around front. Boy 
began chasing it out into the open field.  As mother and father watched 
the light came down from the sky. They described it as a round ball of 
fire and it began to hover over field where boy and dog had run to.  As 
they stood and watched, the mother and father heard the boy start 
screaming for help whereupon the father grabbed his shotgun which was 
right next to the door and began to run out into the field with the 
mother following.  When the father got to the field he saw his son being 
carried away by what looked like little men, into this huge fiery 
looking object.  As it took off the father fired several rounds at the 
object, to no avail.  They found dog, its head was crushed but no sign 
of boy or any other footprints of the little men who apparently carried 
him off.  Father immediately called Darlington police and they 
immediately came out to envestigate.  The official report read that the 
boy had run off and was lost in the forest which bordered the farm.  
Within 48 hours the Air Force made the determination that the family was 
to be relocated and the mother and father were picked up by Air Force 
Intelligence and all personal belongings and possessions were loaded 
into U.S. Air Force trucks and moved to a notrhwestern relocation site. 

The mother was in shock and had to go through a great deal of 
psychotherapy and deprogramming as did father.  One interesting aspect 
about this case was classification under the Air Force report which read 
it was a genuine CE3 and that for the good of the national security the 
mother and father had been relocated to relocation zone Z21-14.  Not 
sure whether this indicated map grid coordinates or latitude longitude.  
According to the report there were at least 4 relocation sites across 
the United States.  Depending upon which type of encounter these people 
had, the report indicated that there were extensive medical facilities 
available at these relocation sites to deal with all medical emergencies 
up to and including radiation poisoning.  The report mentioned a site 
located in the Utah-Nevada area, but no indication of its purpose or 
what it was for. 

Report gave a clear indication of reports of human mutilations, most 
notably was a case witnessed by Air Force personnel in wich an Air Force
Sgt.  E-6 by the name of Jonathon P. Lovette was observed being taken 
captive aboard what appeared to be a UFO at the White Sands Missle Test 
Range in New Mexico. 

This abduction took place in March of 1956 at about 0300 local and was 
witnessed by Major William Cunningham of the United States Air Force 
Missile Test Command near Holloman Air Force Base. 

Major Cunningham and Sgt. Lovette were out in a field downrange from the 
launch sites looking for debris from a missile test when Sgt. Lovette 
went over the ridge of a small sand dune and was out of sight for a 
time. Major Cunningham heard Sgt. Lovette scream in what was described 
as terror or agony.  The Major, thinking the Sgt. had been bitten by a 
snake or something ran over the crest of the dune and saw Sgt.  Lovette 
being dragged into what appeared to him and was descrived as being a  
silvery disk like object which hovered in the air approximately 15 to 20 
feet.  Major Cunningham described what appeared to be a long snake-like 
object which was wrapped around the sargeants legs and was dragging him 
to the craft.  Major Cunningham admittedly froze as the sergeant was 
dragged inside the disk and observed the disc going up into the sky very 
quickly.  Major Cunningham got on the jeep radio and reported the 
incident to Missile Control whereupon Missile Control confirmed a radar 
sighting.  Search parties went out into the field looking for Sgt. 
Lovette.  Major Cunninghams report was taken and he was admitted to the 
White Sands Base Dispensary for observation. The search for Sgt. Lovette 
was continued for 3 days at the end of which his nude body was found 
approximately 10 miles downrange.  The body had been mutilated; the 
tongue had been removed from lower portion of the jaw.  An incision had 
been made just under the tip of the chin and extended all the way back 
to the esophagus and larynx.  He had been emasculated and his eyes had 
been removed.  Also, his anus had been removed and there were comments 
in the report on the apparent surgical skill of the removal of these 
items including the genitalia.  The report commented that the anus and 
genitalia had been removed 'as though a plug' which in the case of the 
anus extended all the way up to the colon.  There was no sign of blood 
within the system.  The initial autopsy report confirmed that the system 
had been completly drained of blood and that there was no vascular 
collapse due to death by bleeding.  Subcomment was added that this was 
unusual because anybody who dies or has complete loss of blood there is 
vascular collapse. Also noted was that when the body was found there 
were a number of dead predatory type birds within the area who 
apparently had died after trying to partake of the sargeants body. There 
were a number of extremely grisly black and white photos.  From all 
indications the body had been exposed to the elements for at least a day 
or two.  The New Mexico sun in the desert is extremely hot and 
debilitating under normal circumstances. 

In this section of the report it also indicated that there were numerous 
occasions in which a UFO tracked alongside of a fired missile and on one 
occasion said missile was observed being taken aboard a UFO while in 

The speeds indicated were absolutely phenomenal.  (English's father had 
told him privately that on more than one occasion he had personally 
tracked what they termed as 'foo fighters'. English's father was an 
electronic engineer by profession and was fairly well versed on 
electronics engineering and design and on more than one occasion he was 
involved in telemetry programming of missiles.  English's father is 
currently a state legislator in Arizona.) 

The report also indicated that there were a number of recovery teams 
that were activated specifically for the purpose of recovering any and 
all evidence of UFO's and UFO sightings. Most notably recorded in 
publication was what they called Recovery Team Alpha.  It was reported 
that Alpha had been extremely active in a number of areas and on certain 
occasions had travelled outside of the continental United States.  Alpha 
was based out of Wright Patterson Air Force Base and was on the move 

Further information in the report consisted of such things as reported 
sightings and where air force planes had been destroyed or had combat 
encounters or had been attacked by UFO's.  Also there were autopsy 
reports of various human mutilations. 

About midway through the report came a section which dealt specifically 
with photographs.  Each photo was labeled and appendixed to certain 
reports.  A number of photos in there dealt with a recovery program of 
some type that took place in the southwestern part of the United States.  
They did not give a location name but they did give grid coordinates for 
that area.  There is no clear indication to exactly where it was.  The 
photos dealt with special teams that were called in to recover a crashed 
UFO. It also dealt with alien bodies and autopsy reports, autopsy type 
photographs, high quality, color, 8 x 10, 5 x 7. 

Photo number 1 showed an alien being on an autopsy table which is a 
metal with funnels and traps underneath to trap fluid and feces.  Body 
appeared to be a little short of 4 feet.  Table was about 7 foot.  No 
clothing on body, no genitalia, body completely heterous, head was 
rounded cranium, slightly enlarged, eyes almond shaped, slits where nose 
would be, extremely small mouth, receeding chin line, holes where ears 
would be.  Photo was taken at angle, side view, looking at body from 45 
degrees elevation, left hand was visible, head was facing to left, body 
was right to left position (head on right, feet on left), eyes were 
closed appeared oriental-looking and almond shaped, left hand slight 
longer than normal, wrist coming down just about 2 to 3 inches above the
knees.  Wrists appeared to be articulated in a fashion that allowed a 
double joint with 3 digit fingers. Wrist was very slender.  There was no
thumb.  A palm was almost non-existent.  The three fingers were direct 
extension from the wrist. 

Color of the skin was bluish gray, dark bluish gray.  At base of the 
body there was a darker color, indicating body was dead for some time.  
Body fluid or blood had settled to base of body.  This indicated that 
body had been examined before beginning autopsy. 

Picture showed beginning stages of autopsy, following standard 
procedure, body was slit from crotch to just under chin and green 
viscuous liquid was in evidence.  There were internal organs but these 
could not be identified. 

Photos thereafter concerned specific areas of internal organs of what 
appeared as small cluster of a multi-valve heart or at least 2 hearts 
within the cadaver.  No accurate description of autopsy report or what 
was found within corpse accompanying photos.  Indication that there was 
no stomach or digestive track per se. Later analysis showed that fluid 
within body was chlorophyl-based liquid which apparently dealt with 
photosynthesis or similar process. The report theorized that nourishment
was taken in through mouth, however since there is no digestive track or
anything of this nature, the waste products were excreted through skin. 

One section of report did specify that cadavers were extremely odorous, 
but this could be accounted for by either deterioration or a number of 
things, but theory was that waste was excreted through pores of skin.  
They could only theorize in report because there was no xenobiology. 

A report by Dr. J. Allen Hynek was recalled vividly which indicated that 
he had also studied the information provided by this particular case and
that he felt that it was indeed a genuine UFO capture and subsequently 
the alien was part of UFO.  Dr. Hynek was non- committal but did however
sign the report. 

Also indicated in report that he did not view bodies personally, but 
viewed photographs and accompanying reports from autopsies. 

Other photos dealt with a number of bodies which were vivisectioned in 
various ways.  At one point, a head was removed from body and 
photographed and autopsy was performed on head. The cranium was opened 
and brain matter was photographed and evident. Interesting thing about 
photo was that there was a ridgebone or dividing partition-type bone 
running directly through center of skull, from front to back, as though 
dividing two brains, one from the other.  This seemed apparent from the 
picture.  The skin was completly removed from cranial structure and the 
skull was layed bare as much as possible. 

At one point the skull was cut directly in half and photo showed 
under-developed esophagus and nasal cavaties.  No clear photo of eye 
orbs as we know them, just photos of complete vivisection of skull 

Numerous photos of flesh of the being starting with cutaneous and 
subcutaneous microphotographic plates. Appeared to be cellular studies 
done under microscope and electron microscope type photos.  Extreme 
magnification of tissue samples. 

This concluded Bill English statement which was transcribed from 2 
casette tapes.  I obtained this handwritten memorandum in August of 1987 
from Paul Bennewitz during my visit with him in Albuquerque.  In 
September of 1988 I received a call from Bill English.  I asked for a 
chance to meet him and discuss the Grudge 13 report.  He said that this 
could be arranged but that the meeting would have to be on his terms for 
security reasons.  He explained that there had been several attempts on 
his life by persons unknown since he had made the casette tapes about 6 
years ago.  We arranged a meeting at a small airport in Virginia on 
September 16.  I was to sit in the lobby with my black flight bag and 
for identification purposes I told Bill what I would be wearing.  I had 
no telephone number for Bill. 

As I walked in the small airport lobby after a 3 hour drive from 
Richmond I immediatily noticed 2 gentlemen who seemed 'out of place' for 
this locale. Both were wearing pin striped 3 piece suits, both had on 
dark glasses.  One was a black gentleman.  One was stationed inside the 
lobby door looking out at the parking lot, one was leaning up against an 
airline counter.  I sat down and after a few minutes was approached by a 
tall, bearded man in jeans and a heavy jacket.  He asked if I wanted to 
have a drink.  We walked outside and he introduced himself as Bill 
English. We drove in Bills car into town to a local bar.  About 5 
minutes after we ordered and had started to talk, the men I had seen at 
the airport came into the bar and sat down.  We left for Bill's house 
and never saw the men again for the next 2 days. 

During the next 2 days I stayed with Bill and his wife and 2 children in 
a small trailer in the middle of a field at his farm.  I asked him 
endless questions concerning the Grudge 13 document, how he happened to 
see it, what happened to him after he saw it and literally thousands of 
questions about the content of the document.  My impression of Bill 
English was that he was totally honest, that he stood behind his 
statements and recollection of the Grudge 13 papers, that he was a 
devoted husband and father to his wifes 2 children.  That Bill English 
was ready to come forward and enter into any debate regarding the 
legitimacy of the document and his recollections thereof.  Of Bills 
compassion for his father and his fathers feelings concerning Bill and 
the reasons for their occasional disagreements.  I have tremendous 
respect for Bill and what he has tried to do in getting this information 
out to the public.  It has been at tremendous personal risk not to 
mention the ridicule by sponsered agents such as Bill Moore who has 
stated that the Grudge 13 papers are a fraud.  (How would Bill Moore 

What follows is additional information about the Grudge 13 papers that I 
obtained from Bill during my visit. In addition to the following Bill 
painstakingly drew many sketches of the photos of different types of 
flying saucers, the equipment obtained from them including a sketch of 
the football sized nuclear generator and sketches of the autopsy photos.

From my notes taken during our 2 day meeting:  Bill described a photo 
taken of 3 live aliens.  Very clear photo, aliens standing against white 
tile wall, looking confused as if they had been shoved, were looking in 
different directions. Report said that aliens had contacted a U.S. 
Intelligence Agency for initial 2 meetings, one at Holloman one at 

U.S. Air Force relocation personnel (for persons involved in close 
encounters) were referred to in report as 'men in black'. 

Major Cunningham was initially accused of murdering Sgt. Jonathon P. 
Lovette. Charges were later dropped. 

Bill English's place of employment in England was RAF Security Services 
Command, RAF Chicksands. 

Entire Grudge 13 report was written as if report was geared toward 
preparation of defenses. 

Report told of ultrasonic weapons found in Germany at the end of WW II 
that could shatter 4" thick armour. 

Report told of sensitive military and industrial areas at which 
personnel experienced missing time. 

Report told about missing time experienced with personnel associated 
with North American x-15 rocket plane project. 

Report stated that there were 17 different extraterrestrial species 
accounted for up to the time of the report. 

Extra-terrestrials were referred to as A.L.F.'s, Alien Life Forms in the 

Report referred to one UFO that was recovered and test flown. The UFO 
blew up as the 2 Air Force pilots aboard attempted to leave the 
atmosphere. English recalls the date as the mid 50's. 

Report refers to flying saucer program as Project 'Red Light' and that a 
secret installation had been constructed in the middle of the Atomic 
Energy Commission testing ground in Nevada. 

At the time of the report 11 alien cadavers were being kept at Wright 
Patterson Air Force Base. 

That additional alien cadavers were being stored at 4 to 5 other medical 

That 2 flying saucers of extraterrestrial origin had been tested in the 
wind tunnel at Langley, Va. 

That at the time of the report, 1 damaged disc was at Elgin Air Force 
Base in Florida. 

That at the time of the report there had been 2 UFO incidents at Ft. 
Riley, Kansas. 

That at the time of the report a detachment of the Alpha recovery team 
was based at Randolph Air force Base. 

The report discussed civilian and military personnel who had been 
terminated 'to eliminate potentially dangerous elements to the national 

That General James Doolittle had been mentioned several times in the 
report with the notation that "His (Doolittle's) predictions might be 
correct".  There was no indication of what those predictions might have 

A short segment containing the quotation, "By presidential order, 
certain aspects of research had been undertaken." 

This report was typed onto disc verbatim from the original document 
which was 


I, William S. English, do hereby state and affirm that I have met with 
Mr. John Olson Lear, on September 16-17, of 1988, and that we discussed 
my original report on my viewing of the Grudge/Bluebook Report 13, in 
June of 1977. 

I Further state that whatever opinions Mr. Lear form or express on this 
matter are entirely his own, and that I stood behind my statements made 
originally when I came forward with this matter, and that I continue to 
stand behind my statements to this date. 

I further state that anyone saying that they have an admission from me 
personally that this was a hoax is a liar and that if I was in fact 
perpetrating a hoax I could have found a better way of doing it. Instead 
I have chosen to allow time to either prove or disprove my claims on the
information on this matter.  Time it seems has proven the validity of my
statements. I welcome the chance to defend my position in either public 
or private debate and will continue to stand behind by original report. 

William S. English September 17, 1988 Gladys, Virginia